MIAA Commissioner's Cup

The 1934-35 academic year marked the first year the MIAA awarded a trophy for the all-sport champion for its member schools. From its inception through the 1997-98 academic year, the honor was issued as the All-Sports Award. Beginning in 1998-99, the award was renamed the Commissioner’s Cup and separate Men’s and Women’s All-Sports awards were established. Due to the COVID-19 pandemic, the MIAA did not award the Commissioner's Cup, and Men's and Women's All-Sports awards for the 2019-20 academic year. Although all sports except cross country were able to compete, it was voted that the Commissioner's Cup would not be awarded for the 2020-21 year due to COVID-19 interruptions and teams opting out of the season.

2024-25

Commissioner’s Cup
1.	Hope	145.5
2.	Calvin	144.5
3.	Trine	138
4.	Adrian	102.5
5.	Albion	102.5
6.	Kalamazoo	89.5
7.	Alma	75
8.	Olivet	60.5

Women’s All-Sports
1.	Calvin	72.5
2.	Hope	72
3.	Trine	70.5
4.	Adrian	48.5
5.	Albion	46.5
6.	Kalamazoo	44
7.	Saint Mary's	34.5
8.	Alma	33
9.	Olivet	21.5

Men’s All-Sports
1.	Hope	73,5
2.	Calvin	72
3.	Trine	67.5
4.	Albion	56
5.	Adrian	54
6.	Kalamazoo	45.5
7.	Alma	42
8.	Olivet	39

2023-24

Commissioner’s Cup
1.	Hope	144.5
2.	Calvin	140.5
3.	Trine	129
4.	Albion	110
5.	Adrian	97
6.	Kalamazoo	91
7.	Alma	84.5
8.	Olivet	64

Women’s All-Sports
1.	Hope	79.5
2.	Calvin	70
3.	Trine	59.5
4.	Albion	53
5.	Adrian	44.5
6.	Kalamazoo	40
7.	Alma	38.5
8.	Saint Mary's	32.5
9.	Olivet	25.5

Men’s All-Sports
1.	Calvin	70.5
2.	Trine	69.5
3.	Hope	65
4.	Albion	57
5.	Adrian	52.5
6.	Kalamazoo	51
7.	Alma	46
8.	Olivet	37.5

2022-23

Commissioner’s Cup
1.	Hope	146.5
2.	Calvin	139
3.	Trine	126
4.	Albion	110
5.	Adrian	100.5
6.	Kalamazoo	88.5
7.	Alma	87
8.	Olivet	67

Women’s All-Sports
1.	Hope	76.5
2.	Calvin	72
3.	Trine	60.5
4.	Albion	49
5.	Adrian	45
6.	Alma	43
7.	Kalamazoo	39
8.	Saint Mary's	34
9.	Olivet	23

Men’s All-Sports
1.	Hope	70
2.	Calvin	67
3.	Trine	65.5
4.	Albion	61
5.	Adrian	55.5
6.	Kalamazoo	49.5
7.	Alma	44
	Olivet	44

2021-22

Commissioner’s Cup
1.	Hope	155
2.	Calvin	135
3.	Trine	130
4.	Albion	116
5.	Adrian	92.5
6.	Kalamazoo	87
7.	Alma	70
8.	Olivet	69

Women’s All-Sports
1.	Hope	78.5
2.	Calvin	65
3.	Trine	64
4.	Albion	59
5.	Kalamazoo	41
6.	Adrian	38
7.	Saint Mary's	37.5
8.	Alma	35.5
9.	Olivet	25

Men’s All-Sports
1.	Hope	76.5
2.	Calvin	70
3.	Trine	66
4.	Albion	57
5.	Adrian	54.5
6.	Kalamazoo	46
7.	Olivet	44
8.	Alma	34.5

2018-19

Commissioner’s Cup
1.	Hope	130
2.	Calvin	124
3.	Trine	116.5
4.	Albion	113
5.	Adrian	86
6.	Kalamazoo	78
7.	Alma	75
8.	Olivet	70

Women’s All-Sports
1.	Hope	69
2.	Calvin	59
3.	Albion	56
4.	Trine	54
5.	Saint Mary's	44.5
6.	Adrian	35.5
	Alma	35.5
8.	Kalamazoo	32.5
9.	Olivet	30.5

Men’s All-Sports
1.	Calvin	65
2.	Trine	62.5
3.	Hope	61
4.	Albion	57
5.	Adrian	50.5
6.	Kalamazoo	45.5
7.	Alma	39.5
	Olivet	39.5

2017-18

Commissioner’s Cup
1.	Calvin	132
2.	Hope	130
3.	Trine	106
4.	Albion	102.5
5.	Adrian	89
6.	Alma	73.5
7.	Olivet	72.5
8.	Kalamazoo	70.5

Women’s All-Sports
1.	Hope	69.5
2.	Calvin	64.5
3.	Albion	52
4.	Trine	48.5
5.	Saint Mary's	45
6.	Adrian	37.5
7.	Alma	36
8.	Olivet	34
9.	Kalamazoo	28.5

Men’s All-Sports
1.	Calvin	67.5
2.	Hope	60.5
3.	Trine	57.5
4.	Adrian	51.5
5.	Albion	50.5
6.	Kalamazoo	42
7.	Olivet	38.5
8.	Alma	37.5

2016-17

Commissioner’s Cup
1.	Calvin	135
2.	Hope	130
3.	Albion	97.5
4.	Trine	97
5.	Alma	88
6.	Adrian	85.5
7.	Kalamazoo	80
8.	Olivet	71

Women’s All-Sports
1.	Calvin	68
	Hope	68
3.	Albion	45.5
4.	Trine	45
5.	Alma	44
6.	Saint Mary's	42
7.	Adrian	36.5
8.	Kalamazoo	35
9.	Olivet	31

Men’s All-Sports
1.	Calvin	67
2.	Hope	62
3.	Albion	52
	Trine	52
5.	Adrian	49
6.	Kalamazoo	45
7	Alma	44
8.	Olivet	40

2015-16

Commissioner’s Cup
1.	Calvin	131
2.	Hope	129.5
3.	Trine	98
4.	Albion	97.5
5.	Alma	89.5
6.	Adrian	87.5
7.	Olivet	72

Women’s All-Sports
1.	Calvin	69
2.	Hope	68
3.	Trine	43.5
4.	Albion	43
5.	Alma	41.5
6.	Adrian	39
7.	Olivet	38
8.	Saint Mary's	36.5

Men’s All-Sports
1.	Calvin	62
2.	Hope	61
3.	Albion	54.5
	Trine	54.5
5.	Adrian	48.5
6.	Alma	48
7.	Olivet	34

2014-15

Commissioner’s Cup
1.	Calvin	133
2.	Hope	125
3.	Trine	92
4.	Adrian	91.5
5.	Albion	84.5
6.	Alma	83.5
7.	Olivet	71

Women’s All-Sports
1.	Hope	67.5
2.	Calvin	65.5
3.	Alma	45.5
4.	Trine	41.5
5.	Albion	41
6.	Saint Mary's	36.5
7.	Olivet	35
8.	Adrian	34

Men’s All-Sports
1.	Calvin	67.5
2.	Adrian	57.5
	Hope	57.5
4.	Trine	50.5
5.	Albion	43.5
6.	Alma	38
7.	Olivet	36

2013-14

Commissioner’s Cup
1.	Hope	211
2.	Calvin	209
3.	Adrian	142
4.	Albion	132
5.	Alma	113
6.	Olivet	108
7.	Trine	101

Women’s All-Sports
1.	Calvin	115
2.	Hope	113
3.	Alma	79
4.	Olivet	70
5.	Adrian	69
6.	Saint Mary's	65
7.	Albion	55
8.	Trine	52

Men’s All-Sports
1.	Hope	98
2.	Calvin	94
3.	Albion	77
4.	Adrian	73
5.	Trine	49
6.	Olivet	38
7.	Alma	34

2012-13

Commissioner’s Cup
1.	Calvin	216
2.	Hope	205
3.	Adrian	157
4.	Trine	131
5.	Alma	127
6.	Albion	118
7.	Olivet	96

Women’s All-Sports
1.	Calvin	114
2.	Hope	112
3.	Alma	91
4.	Adrian	77
5.	Trine	64
6.	Saint Mary's	60
7.	Albion	58
8.	Olivet	54

Men’s All-Sports
1.	Calvin	102
2.	Hope	93
3.	Adrian	80
4.	Trine	67
5.	Albion	60
6.	Olivet	42
7.	Alma	36

2011-12

Commissioner’s Cup
1.	Hope	213
2.	Calvin	182
3.	Adrian	135
4.	Alma	121
5.	Albion	119
6.	Trine	115
7.	Kalamazoo	95
8.	Olivet	78

Women’s All-Sports
1.	Hope	112
2.	Calvin	106
3.	Alma	79
4.	Adrian	72
5.	Saint Mary's	66
6.	Albion	56
7.	Kalamazoo	51
8.	Trine	49
9.	Olivet	43

Men’s All-Sports
1.	Hope	101
2.	Calvin	76
3.	Trine	66
4.	Albion	63
5.	Adrian	63
6.	Kalamazoo	44
7.	Alma	42
8.	Olivet	35

2010-11

Commissioner’s Cup
1.	Hope	206
2.	Calvin	202
3.	Albion	132
4.	Adrian	125
5.	Alma	113
6.	Kalamazoo	98
7.	Olivet	95
8.	Trine	91

Women’s All-Sports
1.	Hope	112
2.	Calvin	106
3.	Alma	72
4.	Albion	71
5.	Saint Mary's	69
6.	Adrian	59
7.	Olivet	58
8.	Kalamazoo	51
9.	Trine	39

Men’s All-Sports
1.	Calvin	96
2.	Hope	94
3.	Adrian	66
4.	Albion	61
5.	Trine	52
6.	Kalamazoo	47
7.	Alma	41
8.	Olivet	37

2009-10

Commissioner’s Cup
1.	Hope	209
2.	Calvin	208
3.	Adrian	130
4.	Albion	128
5.	Alma	98
	Trine	98
7.	Kalamazoo	95
8.	Olivet	84

Women’s All-Sports
1.	Calvin	116
2.	Hope	109
3.	Adrian	67
	Alma	67
5.	Saint Mary's	66
6.	Albion	62
7.	Kalamazoo	47
8.	Trine	46
9.	Olivet	45

Men’s All-Sports
1.	Hope	100
2.	Calvin	92
3.	Albion	66
4.	Adrian	63
5.	Trine	52
6.	Kalamazoo	48
7.	Olivet	39
8.	Alma	31

2008-09

Commissioner’s Cup
1.	Hope	208
2.	Calvin	197
3.	Albion	138
4.	Adrian	109
5.	Olivet	104
6.	Alma	97
7.	Trine	94
8.	Kalamazoo	91

Women’s All-Sports
1.	Hope	114
2.	Calvin	104
3.	Saint Mary's	74
4.	Albion	72
5.	Alma	66
6.	Adrian	51
7.	Olivet	50
8.	Kalamazoo	49
9.	Trine	44

Men’s All-Sports
1.	Hope	94
2.	Calvin	93
3.	Albion	66
4.	Adrian	58
5.	Olivet	54
6.	Trine	50
7.	Kalamazoo	42
8.	Alma	31

2007-08

Commissioner’s Cup
1.	Calvin	202
	Hope	202
3.	Albion	153
4.	Olivet	110
5.	Alma	103
6.	Tri-State	102
7.	Adrian	89
8.	Kalamazoo	79

Women’s All-Sports
1.	Calvin	112
2.	Hope	105
3.	Albion	85
4.	Saint Mary's	75
5.	Alma	58
6.	Adrian	53
7.	Tri-State	51
8.	Olivet	50
9.	Kalamazoo	37

Men’s All-Sports
1.	Hope	97
2.	Calvin	90
3.	Albion	68
4.	Olivet	60
5.	Tri-State	51
6.	Alma	45
7.	Kalamazoo	42
8.	Adrian	36

2006-07

Commissioner’s Cup
1.	Hope	216
2.	Calvin	197
3.	Albion	152
4.	Olivet	116
5.	Alma	102
6.	Kalamazoo	101
	Tri-State	101
8.	Adrian	77

Women’s All-Sports
1.	Calvin	111
2.	Hope	108
3.	Albion	79
4.	Saint Mary's	74
5.	Olivet	62
6.	Alma	60
7.	Kalamazoo	58
8.	Tri-State	47
9.	Adrian	36

Men’s All-Sports
1.	Hope	108
2.	Calvin	86
3.	Albion	73
4.	Olivet	54
	Tri-State	54
6.	Kalamazoo	46
7.	Alma	42
8.	Adrian	41

2005-06

Commissioner’s Cup
1.	Hope	216
2.	Calvin	198
3.	Albion	167
4.	Olivet	125
5.	Alma	108
6.	Kalamazoo	99
7.	Adrian	63
	Tri-State	63

Women’s All-Sports
1.	Hope	117
2.	Calvin	109
3.	Albion	87
4.	Saint Mary's	78
5.	Alma	66
	Olivet	66
7.	Kalamazoo	47
8.	Adrian	25
	Tri-State	25

Men’s All-Sports
1.	Hope	99
2.	Calvin	89
3.	Albion	80
4.	Kalamazoo	52
5.	Olivet	51
6.	Alma	42
7.	Adrian	38
	Tri-State	38

2004-05

Commissioner’s Cup
1.	Hope	202
2.	Calvin	198
3.	Albion	175
4.	Alma	125
5.	Kalamazoo	103
6.	Olivet	100
7.	Tri-State	74
8.	Adrian	61

Women’s All-Sports
1.	Calvin	110
	Hope	110
3.	Albion	93
4.	Alma	76
5.	Kalamazoo	62
6.	Saint Mary's	54
7.	Olivet	52
8.	Tri-State	37
9.	Adrian	27

Men’s All-Sports
1.	Hope	92
2.	Calvin	88
3.	Albion	82
4.	Alma	49
5.	Olivet	48
6.	Kalamazoo	41
7.	Tri-State	37
8.	Adrian	34

2003-04

Commissioner’s Cup
1.	Hope	177
2.	Calvin	164
3.	Albion	142
4.	Alma	105
5.	Kalamazoo	92
6.	Olivet	60
7.	Adrian	59

Women’s All-Sports
1.	Calvin	97
2.	Hope	92
3.	Albion	69
	Alma	69
5.	Saint Mary's	57
6.	Kalamazoo	50
7.	Olivet	30
8.	Adrian	26

Men’s All-Sports
1.	Hope	85
2.	Albion	73
3.	Calvin	67
4.	Kalamazoo	42
5.	Alma	36
6.	Adrian	33
7.	Olivet	30

2002-03

Commissioner’s Cup
1.	Hope	174
2.	Calvin	147
3.	Albion	133
4.	Alma	120
5.	Kalamazoo	103
6.	Adrian	66
7.	Olivet	61

Women’s All-Sports
1.	Hope	92
2.	Calvin	86
3.	Albion	77
4.	Alma	65
5.	Kalamazoo	58
6.	Saint Mary's	43
7.	Adrian	38
8.	Olivet	26

Men’s All-Sports
1.	Hope	82
2.	Calvin	61
3.	Albion	56
4.	Alma	55
5.	Kalamazoo	45
6.	Olivet	35
7.	Adrian	28

2001-02

Commissioner’s Cup
1.	Hope	175
2.	Calvin	166
3.	Albion	128
	Kalamazoo	128
5.	Alma	111
6.	Adrian	71
7.	Olivet	39

Women’s All-Sports
1.	Hope	94
2.	Calvin	86
3.	Albion	74
4.	Kalamazoo	73
5.	Alma	65
6.	Adrian	41
	Saint Mary's	41
8.	Olivet	15

Men’s All-Sports
1.	Hope	81
2.	Calvin	80
3.	Kalamazoo	55
4.	Albion	54
5.	Alma	46
6.	Adrian	30
7.	Olivet	24

2000-01

Commissioner’s Cup
1.	Hope	179
2.	Calvin	157
3.	Albion	139
4.	Alma	126
5.	Kalamazoo	119
6.	Adrian	51
7.	Olivet	44

Women’s All-Sports
1.	Hope	95
2.	Albion	85
3.	Calvin	83
4.	Alma	70
5.	Kalamazoo	62
6.	Saint Mary's	42
7.	Adrian	34
8.	Olivet	18

Men’s All-Sports
1.	Hope	84
2.	Calvin	74
3.	Kalamazoo	57
4.	Alma	56
5.	Albion	54
6.	Olivet	26
7.	Adrian	17

1999-2000

Commissioner’s Cup
1.	Calvin	178
2.	Hope	176
3.	Alma	131
4.	Albion	121
5.	Kalamazoo	110
6.	Olivet	56
7.	Adrian	49

Women’s All-Sports
1.	Hope	102
2.	Calvin	95
3.	Albion	68
4.	Alma	68
5.	Kalamazoo	55
6.	Saint Mary's	46
7.	Olivet	29
8.	Adrian	24

Men’s All-Sports
1.	Calvin	83
2.	Hope	74
3.	Alma	63
4.	Kalamazoo	55
5.	Albion	53
6.	Olivet	27
7.	Adrian	25

1998-99

Commissioner’s Cup
1.	Hope	213
2.	Calvin	193
3.	Albion	151
4.	Alma	137
	Kalamazoo	137
6.	Olivet	90
7.	Adrian	70
8.	Defiance	64

Women’s All-Sports
1.	Hope	118
2.	Calvin	109
3.	Albion	80
4.	Kalamazoo	73
5.	Alma	69
6.	Saint Mary's	64
7.	Olivet	45
8.	Defiance	37
9.	Adrian	24

Men’s All-Sports
1.	Hope	95
2.	Calvin	83
3.	Albion	71
4.	Alma	68
5.	Kalamazoo	64
6.	Olivet	45
7.	Adrian	36
8.	Defiance	27

All-Sports Standings

1997-98
1.	Hope	165
2.	Calvin	138
3.	Alma	109
4.	Albion	103
5.	Kalamazoo	102
6.	Adrian	62
7.	Olivet	48

1996-97
1.	Hope	161
2.	Calvin	146
3.	Alma	122
4.	Kalamazoo	116
5.	Albion	99
6.	Adrian	46
7.	Olivet	43

1995-96
1.	Calvin	151
2.	Hope	147
3.	Alma	122
	Kalamazoo	122
5.	Albion	107
6.	Adrian	45
7.	Olivet	30

1994-95
1.	Hope	152
2.	Calvin	138
3.	Albion	119
	Alma	119
5.	Kalamazoo	113
6.	Adrian	54
7.	Olivet	34

1993-94
1.	Hope	147
2.	Calvin	141
3.	Kalamazoo	124
4.	Albion	116
5.	Alma	114
6.	Adrian	56
7.	Olivet	36

1992-93
1.	Calvin	147
2.	Hope	134
3.	Albion	122
4.	Alma	114
5.	Kalamazoo	112
6.	Adrian	73
7.	Olivet	31

1991-92
1.	Hope	137
2.	Calvin	130
3.	Kalamazoo	116
4.	Albion	106
5.	Alma	102
6.	Adrian	57
7.	Olivet	50

1990-91
1.	Calvin	138
2.	Hope	135
3.	Kalamazoo	112
4.	Alma	98
5.	Albion	96
6.	Adrian	68
7.	Olivet	35

1989-90
1.	Calvin	144
2.	Hope	141
3.	Kalamazoo	115
4.	Albion	89
	Alma	89
6.	Adrian	63
7.	Olivet	35

1988-89
1.	Calvin	135
2.	Hope	126
3.	Kalamazoo	99
4.	Alma	98
5.	Albion	94
6.	Adrian	47
7.	Olivet	29

1987-88
1.	Hope	150
2.	Calvin	139
3.	Alma	100
4.	Albion	92
	Kalamazoo	92
6.	Adrian	57
7.	Olivet	32

1986-87
1.	Hope	140
2.	Calvin	128
3.	Alma	103
4.	Albion	94
5.	Kalamazoo	75
6.	Adrian	66
7.	Olivet	36

1985-86
1.	Hope	135
2.	Calvin	124
3.	Albion	102
4.	Alma	96
5.	Kalamazoo	74
6.	Adrian	64
7.	Olivet	40

1984-85
1.	Hope	135
2.	Calvin	120
3.	Alma	101
4.	Albion	100
5.	Kalamazoo	69
6.	Adrian	53
7.	Olivet	39

1983-84
1.	Hope	130
2.	Calvin	121
3.	Alma	119
4.	Albion	106
5.	Kalamazoo	73
6.	Adrian	65
7.	Olivet	56

1982-83
1.	Hope	139
2.	Calvin	123
3.	Albion	116
4.	Alma	107
5.	Kalamazoo	82
6.	Olivet	60
7.	Adrian	54

1981-82
1.	Hope	135
2.	Albion	129
3.	Calvin	121
4.	Alma	90
5.	Kalamazoo	84
6.	Adrian	67
7.	Olivet	61

1980-81
1.	Hope	79
2.	Albion	69
3.	Calvin	61
4.	Alma	58
5.	Kalamazoo	49
6.	Olivet	48
7.	Adrian	29

1979-80
1.	Hope	75
2.	Calvin	70
3.	Kalamazoo	64
4.	Alma	61
5.	Albion	56
6.	Olivet	51
7.	Adrian	25

1978-79
1.	Albion	78
2.	Hope	65
3.	Kalamazoo	61
4.	Alma	58
5.	Calvin	54
6.	Olivet	53
7.	Adrian	33

1977-78
1.	Albion	68
2.	Alma	67
3.	Calvin	64
4.	Hope	61
5.	Kalamazoo	57
6.	Adrian	55
7.	Olivet	32

1976-77
1.	Calvin	69
2.	Hope	67
3.	Albion	65
	Kalamazoo	65
5.	Alma	63
6.	Adrian	45
7.	Olivet	24

1975-76
1.	Kalamazoo	73
2.	Alma	72
3.	Calvin	68
4.	Albion	65
5.	Hope	57
6.	Olivet	35
7.	Adrian	33

1974-75
1.	Kalamazoo	71
2.	Alma	70
	Calvin	70
4.	Hope	56
5.	Albion	55
6.	Olivet	47
7.	Adrian	35

1973-74
1.	Kalamazoo	79
2.	Calvin	69
3.	Albion	64
4.	Alma	63
5.	Hope	60
6.	Olivet	37
7.	Adrian	18

1972-73
1.	Kalamazoo	72
2.	Albion	69
3.	Alma	61
4.	Calvin	59
5.	Hope	54
6.	Olivet	53
7.	Adrian	31

1971-72
1.	Kalamazoo	72
2.	Albion	64
3.	Alma	62
	Calvin	62
5.	Hope	57
6.	Adrian	45
7.	Olivet	39

1970-71
1.	Albion	66
2.	Kalamazoo	64
3.	Calvin	62
4.	Alma	61
5.	Adrian	58
6.	Hope	52
7.	Olivet	37

1969-70
1.	Alma	65
2.	Albion	61
3.	Calvin	55
4.	Hope	45
5.	Kalamazoo	44
6.	Adrian	36
7.	Olivet	30

1968-69
1.	Calvin	54
2.	Hope	53
3.	Kalamazoo	52
4.	Alma	50
5.	Albion	49
6.	Adrian	18
	Olivet	18

1967-68
1.	Alma	62
2.	Calvin	47
3.	Hope	46
4.	Albion	45
5.	Kalamazoo	42
6.	Adrian	34
7.	Olivet	18

1966-67
1.	Hope	61
2.	Albion	55
3.	Kalamazoo	52
4.	Calvin	35
5.	Alma	33
6.	Adrian	30
7.	Olivet	24

1965-66
1.	Hope	62
2.	Albion	58
3.	Calvin	48
4.	Kalamazoo	38
5.	Alma	33
6.	Adrian	29
7.	Olivet	22

1964-65
1.	Albion	71
2.	Hope	54
3.	Calvin	51
4.	Kalamazoo	39
5.	Olivet	36
6.	Alma	27
7.	Adrian	16

1963-64
1.	Hope	58
2.	Albion	55
3.	Calvin	51
4.	Kalamazoo	48
5.	Alma	44
6.	Adrian	30
7.	Olivet	8

1962-63
1.	Kalamazoo	69
2.	Hope	54
3.	Albion	49
4.	Calvin	40
5.	Alma	31
6.	Adrian	30
7.	Olivet	21

1961-62
1.	Kalamazoo	70
2.	Albion	60
3.	Hope	48
4.	Calvin	44
5.	Alma	34
6.	Olivet	21
7.	Adrian	17

1960-61
1.	Albion	59
2.	Kalamazoo	58
3.	Calvin	46
4.	Adrian	42
5.	Hope	40
6.	Alma	30
7.	Olivet	19

1959-60
1.	Kalamazoo	69
2.	Hope	64
3.	Hillsdale	58
4.	Calvin	56
5.	Albion	54
6.	Alma	47
7.	Adrian	33
8.	Olivet	11

1958-59
1.	Albion	74
2.	Hope	73
3.	Kalamazoo	63
4.	Hillsdale	52
5.	Alma	48
6.	Calvin	44
7.	Adrian	26
8.	Olivet	12

1957-58
1.	Albion	76
2.	Kalamazoo	68
3.	Hillsdale	67
4.	Hope	66
5.	Alma	53
6.	Calvin	43
7.	Adrian	10
8.	Olivet	7

1956-57
1.	Kalamazoo	80
2.	Hope	77
3.	Albion	71
4.	Hillsdale	53
5.	Alma	40
6.	Calvin	38
7.	Adrian	21
8.	Olivet	12

1955-56
1.	Albion	75
2.	Kalamazoo	67
3.	Hillsdale	62
4.	Hope	55
5.	Alma	51
6.	Calvin	46
7.	Adrian	25
8.	Olivet	11

1954-55
1.	Albion	76
2.	Kalamazoo	71
3.	Hope	60
4.	Hillsdale	52
5.	Alma	42
6.	Adrian	32
7.	Olivet	18

1953-54
1.	Hope	83
2.	Albion	77
3.	Hillsdale	57
4.	Alma	56
5.	Calvin	36
6.	Kalamazoo	35
7.	Adrian	27
8.	Olivet	10

1952-53
1.	Hope	68
2.	Albion	67
3.	Kalamazoo	46
4.	Alma	37
5.	Hillsdale	35
6.	Adrian	29
7.	Olivet	10

1951-52
1.	Albion	54
2.	Hope	51
3.	Kalamazoo	39
4.	Alma	35
5.	Hillsdale	28
6.	Adrian	2

1950-51
1.	Albion	55
2.	Kalamazoo	40
3.	Hope	36
4.	Hillsdale	34
5.	Alma	32
6.	Adrian	13

1949-50
1.	Albion	50
2.	Kalamazoo	45
3.	Hope	39
4.	Hillsdale	36
5.	Alma	25
6.	Adrian	10

1948-49
1.	Alma	46
2.	Albion	44
3.	Hillsdale	42
4.	Kalamazoo	34
5.	Hope	27
6.	Adrian	17

1947-48
1.	Albion	48
2.	Kalamazoo	41
3.	Hope	35
4.	Hillsdale	34
5.	Alma	29
6.	Adrian	21

1946-47
1.	Hope	40
2.	Albion	31
3.	Kalamazoo	27
4.	Alma	26
5.	Hillsdale	20
6.	Adrian	10

1941-42
Alma was the all-sports champion, but standings are incomplete.

1940-41
1.	Alma	42
2.	Albion	34
3.	Kalamazoo	30
4.	Hope	24
5.	Hillsdale	13
6.	Adrian	7

1939-40
1.	Albion	51
2.	Kalamazoo	46
3.	Alma	37
4.	Hope	36
5.	Hillsdale	24
6.	Olivet	11
7.	Adrian	5

1938-39
1.	Kalamazoo	53
2.	Albion	48
3.	Alma	31
4.	Hope	28
5.	Olivet	24
6.	Hillsdale	20
7.	Adrian	4

1937-38
1.	Kalamazoo	60
2.	Albion	41
	Hope	41
4.	Alma	27
5.	Hillsdale	19
6.	Olivet	14
7.	Adrian	6

1936-37
1.	Hope	41
2.	Kalamazoo	37
3.	Albion	25
4.	Olivet	22
5.	Hillsdale	13
6.	Alma	12

1935-36
1.	Kalamazoo	36
2.	Hope	33
3.	Albion	28
4.	Olivet	24
5.	Alma	18
6.	Hillsdale	11

1934-35
1.	Kalamazoo	41
2.	Hope	35
3.	Albion	27
4.	Hillsdale	21
5.	Alma	14
6.	Olivet	12

NOTES:

(1) Beginning in 1981-82, the all-sports award is based on finishes in men's and women's sports.

(2) Beginning in 1992-93, scoring formula changed to 8 of 9 sports for both men and women.

(3) Beginning in 1998-99, the award was renamed the Commissioner's Cup and separate Men's and Women's Awards were established.

(4) Beginning in 2014-15, a new scoring formula was introduced awarding an equal number of points to the MIAA champion, regardless of sport or gender.

(5) The place of Kalamazoo College in the Commissioner’s Cup and All-Sports standings in 2012-13, 2013-14, 2014-15 and 2015-16 were vacated by order of the MIAA President’s Council.

(6) Beginning in 2014-15, a new scoring formula was introduced awarding an equal number of points to the MIAA champion, regardless of sport or gender.